| Divisional | |||||||||||||
| Year | Team | W | L | Pct | GB | L10 | Strk | Recent | RF | RA | Mgn | Mgc | |
| 1874 | Philadelphia Southworths | 39 | 16 | .709 | - |   | 7-3 | W6 | wwwwwwlwll | 862 | 369 | 493 | 0 |
| 1874 | Minneapolis Millers | 33 | 22 | .600 | 6 |   | 5-5 | W1 | wlllwwwlwl | 1177 | 714 | 463 |   |
| 1874 | Chicago Whales | 32 | 23 | .582 | 7 |   | 6-4 | L1 | lwwlllwwww | 833 | 455 | 378 |   |
| 1874 | Springfield Burning Bridges | 29 | 26 | .527 | 10 |   | 5-5 | L1 | lwwwwllllw | 933 | 587 | 346 |   |
| 1874 | Riddlers Medevil BBC | 19 | 36 | .345 | 20 |   | 5-5 | W1 | wllwlwwwll | 904 | 1092 | -188 |   |
| 1874 | Frankford Yellowjackets | 13 | 42 | .236 | 26 |   | 2-8 | L8 | llllllllww | 607 | 2099 | -1492 |   |
| Wildcard | ||||||||||
| Year | Team | W | L | Pct | GB | L10 | Strk | Recent | Mgc | |
| 1874 | Philadelphia Southworths | 39 | 16 | .709 | na |   | 7-3 | W6 | wwwwwwlwll |   |
| 1874 | Minneapolis Millers | 33 | 22 | .600 | - |   | 5-5 | W1 | wlllwwwlwl | 0 |
| 1874 | Chicago Whales | 32 | 23 | .582 | 1 |   | 6-4 | L1 | lwwlllwwww |   |
| 1874 | Springfield Burning Bridges | 29 | 26 | .527 | 4 |   | 5-5 | L1 | lwwwwllllw |   |
| 1874 | Riddlers Medevil BBC | 19 | 36 | .345 | 14 |   | 5-5 | W1 | wllwlwwwll |   |
| 1874 | Frankford Yellowjackets | 13 | 42 | .236 | 20 |   | 2-8 | L8 | llllllllww |   |
| Expanded1 | |||||||||
| Year | Team | Home | Road | Grass | Turf | vsLHP | vsRHP | Div | InterLg |
| 1874 | Philadelphia Southworths | 22-6 | 17-10 | 39-16 |   |   | 39-16 | 39-16 |   |
| 1874 | Minneapolis Millers | 19-8 | 14-14 | 33-22 |   |   | 33-22 | 33-22 |   |
| 1874 | Chicago Whales | 14-13 | 18-10 | 32-23 |   |   | 32-23 | 32-23 |   |
| 1874 | Springfield Burning Bridges | 16-11 | 13-15 | 29-26 |   |   | 29-26 | 29-26 |   |
| 1874 | Riddlers Medevil BBC | 14-14 | 5-22 | 19-36 |   |   | 19-36 | 19-36 |   |
| 1874 | Frankford Yellowjackets | 8-20 | 5-22 | 13-42 |   |   | 13-42 | 13-42 |   |
| Expanded2 | ||||||
| Year | Team | Lead7 | Tied7 | Trail7 | 1-run | Extra |
| 1874 | Philadelphia Southworths | 35-3 | 1-1 | 3-12 | 7-6 | 1-2 |
| 1874 | Minneapolis Millers | 22-3 | 1-1 | 10-18 | 7-3 | 2-2 |
| 1874 | Chicago Whales | 26-3 | 2-0 | 4-20 | 5-7 | 2-0 |
| 1874 | Springfield Burning Bridges | 24-5 | 1-0 | 4-21 | 2-8 | 1-1 |
| 1874 | Riddlers Medevil BBC | 16-7 | 0-3 | 3-26 | 7-7 | 0-2 |
| 1874 | Frankford Yellowjackets | 10-5 | 1-1 | 2-36 | 6-3 | 1-0 |